fbpx

Conference for Truth and Trust Online Wrapped Up for 2020 :

Combating misleading information, hoaxes, half-truths and outright lies is a discouraging business and can feel like a losing battle. However, many researchers and media experts continue to keep up the fight. This past October a group of technologists, academics, and platform owners got together for the second meeting of the Conference for Truth and Trust Online to discuss the current situation, ways to better understand how and why the phenomenon happens as well as technical innovations to remedy the problem.

The program committee was chaired by Emiliano De Cristofaro (University College London) and Preslav Nakov (Qatar Computing Research Institute, HBKU). Not surprisingly, much of the content and focus of this year’s conference centered on the dangers of false information related to the current COVID-19 crisis and the U.S. presidential election, which took place just three weeks after the event. In times of a crisis, quality information is especially important, but that’s exactly when bad actors spread rumors and misleading claims. Nicole Aitken from Full Fact, a U.K. fact-checking organization, reported that in times of a crisis, people actively look for information trying to understand how their lives might be impacted. She added that the stress of a crisis also means that people are less able to process complex facts, making it harder to discern real information from the noise. And, unfortunately, real-world harms can result from false information online.

The first day’s keynote speaker Meeyoung Cha, Associate Professor at the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, cited several instances of the consequences of believing wrong information about the pandemic. Some of her examples were almost comical, such as a security guard at a U.K. office building asking people to hold their breath for ten seconds as a health screening before allowing them to enter the building. Others were more dire, such as an incident at a Korean church where church members believed they would be protected from the virus by spraying salt water into each other’s mouths, leading to a superspreading event at the church. Others are even tragic. Nigeria has seen a spike in hydroxichloroquine poisoning, for example.

Cha’s broader and more important message was about how false information spreads. Comparing the spreading patterns of reliable versus false information in social graphs reveals distinct differences. A key part of the fight against bad information is understanding how and why it is disseminated to help lead to effective remedies.

Understanding How Disinformation Spreads

Indeed understanding how mis- and disinformation spreads was a recurring theme throughout the conference. Claire Wardle, the U.S. Director of First Draft, a non-profit organization dedicated to fighting disinformation online, emphasized that false information is generally not broadcast to a large audience as in traditional media, at least not when it’s getting started. “One thing I really want to stress in this talk is that too many of us who work in the quality information space still think about this in a broadcast way.” She went on to explain how misinformation propagates through clustered networks of people. “Information flows between small peer-to-peer groups. People that are trusted take information, and they twist it into a narrative that fits with their community.” She believes that those working in the quality information space need to understand that information moves in different ways now, and the old techniques need to adapt.

“One thing I really want to stress in this talk is that too many of us who work in the quality information space still think about this in a broadcast way.”

As if anticipating Wardle’s message, a group of journalists from the BBC (Rebecca Skippage, Alistair Coleman, Olga Robinson, and Shayan Sardarizadeh) covered the ways their group had to quickly adapt their approach as news of the virus originating in Wuhan, China started to break. The parallel infodemic that spread along with the virus presented new challenges to traditional reporting. Having created a disinformation observation team as early as 2018, the BBC seems to have been better prepared for the infodemic than the world was for the coronavirus pandemic.

Since disinformation normally originates and starts to spread online, traditional media companies face a dilemma. A major concern for the BBC team when reporting on false information is not to amplify it so as not to bring more attention to misleading claims. Journalists need to understand how and where bad information has been spreading. The BBC team has settled on an approach of not bringing attention to misinformation unless it is already widely spread or has the potential to create real damage, such as harmful medical advice.

Mass media professionals generally try not to bring attention to bad information, but as disinformation moves through networks and jumps from cluster to cluster reaching larger and larger numbers of people, it can get laundered along the way, so that its apparent provenance is less dubious. Once it reaches celebrities and prominent people, it’s harder for the news media to ignore it. Moreover, in this networked environment, even obscure sites and sources can originate wild claims. Existing networks like QAnon will pick up bogus information and spread it throughout their existing connections causing it to go far beyond its original, sketchy origins.

Truth and Trust

Counteracting Disinformation

Nearly all of the presenters focused on not only the problem of disinformation, but also potential remedies. Several papers and presentations covered various aspects of fact-checking and other ways to counter disinformation campaigns.

Meeyoung Cha’s keynote included a description of the successes her team has had with their “Facts Before Rumors” program. The program attempts to predict where false information is likely to spread and then precede it with reliable information, providing a kind of inoculation to those about to be infected with false claims. If credible voices can get their message out early enough they can stanch the flow of bad information. Their research showed that fact-checks must happen before people have really absorbed bad claims. Once they have accepted a claim, exposure to the fact-check is less likely to be effective. The group has created simple and interesting infographics that debunk misleading claims.

Of course, different remedies have shortcomings, and people are justifiably sensitive to interference with free expression. Satire and sarcasm are likely to be incorrectly flagged by automated verification, and fact-checking tools are likely to make mistakes. Whether automated or manual, fact-checkers have to be considered trustworthy if they are to have any positive impact. The Director of the International Fact-Checking Network, Baybars Örsek, described his organization’s attempts to establish more trust in fact-checkers by promoting higher standards in their work.

Perversely, false fact-checking has even been used as a method to spread disinformation. The Poynter Institute has noted that fake fact-checkers are one of the latest trends in online disinformation. Sarah Samwel from Carleton University, presented details of a website devoted to denying the Armenian genocide that took place in 1915. These fake sites try to signal their integrity by aping the content of legitimate fact-checking sites. They adopt similar language and imagery to hide their true motives.

Even when information is correctly labeled, consumers have different reactions to fact-checked content. Emily Saltz (Partnership on AI and First Draft) together with Claire Leibowicz found that attitudes about fact-checking labels vary. Much like the contentious issues they try to clarify, fact-checking labels have people divided. Some consider the labels helpful, providing context to an issue while others feel the labels are paternalistic, as if platforms are spoon feeding them information. They distrust the motives behind labeling.

TTO’s Origins and What’s to Come

Due to the pandemic, this year’s conference took place online, but that didn’t interfere with its goal of providing a single gathering for all kinds of people involved in misinformation. “Lots of computer science conferences have related workshops or side events, but we thought there was a need for a single conference focused entirely on online harm,” explained Guillaume Bouchard who is one of the originators of the TTO conference and also a co-founder of [CheckStep] “We wanted a conference that would be independent and that would bring together multiple academic disciplines to address the problems holistically with real solutions rather than just talking about the situation.”

Conference content was comprised of both technical papers and talks. The talks were designed to allow scholars, activists, developers, lawyers, ethics experts, fact-checkers, public servants, journalists, and all around researchers to discuss early ideas even before they’ve been fully fleshed out from their work in the field. The virtual conference was ‘packed’ with almost 400 participants from around the world, across thirty-five countries and five continents. Over fifty volunteers helped run the conference, which took place on October 16 and 17. In addition to the topics already mentioned, papers and presentations also covered bias, polarization, propaganda, and ways to model and classify text and analyze the news.

Next year’s conference is already in the works and [CheckStep]’s own Deputy Head of Research, Isabelle Augenstein, will co-chair the program committee. No doubt much will have changed in a year’s time, but we can expect that efforts to spread disinformation will continue. She’s hoping to see some progress by the time the group convenes again. “I hope by next year, we as a community will have more insights into how fact-checking can actually work in the real world — how we can use fact-checking effectively to warn people about mis- and disinformation, which includes changing peoples’ minds.”

We’ll be keeping an eye out as the planning shapes up looking forward to an equally informative and productive conference in 2021.

If you would like more information or are exploring options for AI enhanced moderation for your platform, contact us at contact@checkstep.com. Alternatively, you can also visit our website www.checkstep.com.

By Checkstep on December 14, 2020 – Exported from Medium on July 11, 2023.

More posts like this

We want content moderation to enhance your users’ experience and so they can find their special one more easily.

How Video Game Bullying is Threatening the Future of the Industry

Video games have become an integral part of modern entertainment, offering immersive experiences and interactive gameplay. With the rise in popularity of online multiplayer games, a dark side has emerged : video game bullying. This pervasive issue threatens the well-being of players and the reputation of the entire video game industry. In this article, we…
4 minutes

How to Build a Safe Social Media Platform without Sacrificing the User’s Freedom

It was once unthinkable that social media would become an integral aspect of daily life, but here we are, relying on it for communication, information, entertainment, and even shaping our social interactions. It’s brought to our lives a whole new set of rules, and now that online duality is expected, the balance between safety and…
6 minutes

Digital Services Act (DSA) Transparency Guide [+Free Templates]

The Digital Services Act (DSA) is a comprehensive set of laws that aims to regulate digital services and platforms to ensure transparency, accountability, and user protection. In other words, it’s the European Union’s way of regulating and harmonizing separate laws under one universal piece of legislation to prevent illegal and harmful activities online and the…
7 minutes

The Evolution of Content Moderation Rules Throughout The Years

The birth of the digital public sphere This article is contributed by Ahmed Medien. Online forums and social marketplaces have become a large part of the internet in the past 20 years since the early bulletin boards on the internet and AOL chat rooms. Today, users moved primarily to social platforms, platforms that host user-generated content. These…
7 minutes

How AI is Revolutionizing Content Moderation in Social Media Platforms

Social media platforms have become an integral part of our lives, connecting us with friends, family, and the world at large. Still, with the exponential growth of user-generated content, ensuring a safe and positive user experience has become a daunting task. This is where Artificial Intelligence (AI) comes into play, revolutionizing the way social media…
3 minutes

Outsourcing Content Moderation

Outsourcing content moderation has become an essential aspect of managing online platforms in the digital age. With the exponential growth of user-generated content, businesses are faced with the challenge of maintaining a safe and inclusive environment for their users while protecting their brand reputation. To address this, many companies are turning to outsourcing content moderation…
4 minutes

From Trolls to Fair Play: The Transformative Impact of AI Moderation in Gaming

The Online Battlefield The online gaming community, once a haven for enthusiasts to connect and share their passion, has faced the growing challenge of toxic behaviour and harassment. Teenagers and young adults are still the main demographic of players, and as multiplayer games became more popular, so did instances of trolling, hate speech, and other…
4 minutes

Minor protection : 3 updates you should make to comply with DSA provisions

Introduction While the EU already has some rules to protect children online, such as those found in the Audiovisual Media Services Directive, the Digital Services Act (DSA) introduces specific obligations for platforms. As platforms adapt to meet the provisions outlined in the DSA Minor Protection, it's important for businesses to take proactive measures to comply…
5 minutes

Trust and Safety Teams: Ensuring User Protection

As the internet becomes an integral part of our daily lives, companies must prioritize the safety and security of their users. This responsibility falls on trust and safety teams, whose primary goal is to protect users from fraud, abuse, and other harmful behavior.  Trust and Safety Teams Objectives  The Role of Trust and Safety Teams…
6 minutes

Building Trust and Safety Online: The Power of AI Content Moderation in Community Forums

Community forums are providing spaces for individuals to connect, share ideas, and build relationships. However, maintaining a safe and welcoming environment in these forums is crucial for fostering trust and ensuring the well-being of community members. To address this challenge, many forums are turning to the power of artificial intelligence (AI) content moderation. In this…
3 minutes

Designing for Trust in 2023: How to Create User-Friendly Designs that Keep Users Safe

The Significance of designing for trust in the Digital World In today's digital landscape, building trust with users is essential for operating a business online. Trust is the foundation of successful user interactions and transactions, it is key to encouraging users to share personal information, make purchases, and interact with website content. Without trust, users…
5 minutes

The Evolution of Online Communication: Cultivating Safe and Respectful Interactions

What was once an outrageous dream is now a mundane reality. Going from in-person communication to being able to hold a conversation from thousands of kilometres away has been nothing short of revolutionary. From the invention of email to the meteoric rise of social media and video conferencing, the ways we connect, share, and interact…
5 minutes

The Role of a Content Moderator: Ensuring Safety and Integrity in the Digital World

In today's digital world, the role of a content moderator is central to ensuring the safety and integrity of online platforms. Content moderators are responsible for reviewing and moderating user-generated content to ensure that it complies with the platform's policies and guidelines, and the laws and regulations. Their work is crucial in creating a safe…
5 minutes

Educational Content: Enhancing Online Safety with AI

The internet has revolutionized the field of education, offering new resources and opportunities for learning. With the increased reliance on online platforms and digital content, it is now a priority to ensure the safety and security of educational spaces. This is where artificial intelligence (AI) plays a big role. By using the power of AI,…
3 minutes

Prevent unwanted content from reaching your platform

Speak to one of our experts and learn about using AI to protect your platform
Talk to an expert