fbpx

Expert’s Corner with NewsGuard’s Veena McCoole & Sarah Brandt

Two experts from NewsGuard explain their organization’s hands-on approach to dealing with misinformation

For this month’s Expert’s Corner, we get to hear from two senior members of the venerable NewsGuard internet trust tool. Veena McCoole and Sarah Brandt both manage and facilitate partnerships at NewsGuard, an organization that provides online safety for brands, individual readers and indeed even democracies, eschewing algorithms in favor of the human expertise of trained journalists. NewsGuard publishes reports on misinformation generally as well as detailed reviews of individual news sites evaluating them according to various criteria with an emphasis on transparency of the organization and the credibility of the information they publish.

Veena is the Vice President of Strategic Partnerships managing UK partnerships with technology platforms, advertisers, researchers, schools and libraries. Sarah is the Executive Vice President, Partnerships for NewsGuard, based in Austin, Texas. She manages NewsGuard’s global partnerships with schools, libraries, researchers, technology platforms, ad tech providers, and security companies. Prior to joining NewsGuard, Sarah worked as an Associate Consultant for Bain & Company.

1. What was the motivation behind NewsGuard? While researchers often employ fact checks to best deal with misinformation, are they truly effective?

NewsGuard was founded in 2018 to combat misinformation and restore trust in the media, with the belief that journalism — instead of algorithms — can effectively ensure online safety for users, brands, and democracies. By deploying trained journalists to manually evaluate the credibility and transparency practices of news and information websites, our licensing partners — including advertising companies, technology platforms, content moderators, reputation management software companies, and news aggregators — can leverage this human-vetted data to make informed decisions about which news websites to trust.

Fact checks address misinformation by setting the record straight after a falsehood is spread, but this approach has its limitations. By definition, fact checks happen after the fact — after erroneous information has circulated and caused harm. Moreover, fact checks infrequently reach the same people who saw the original misstatement. Recognizing the shortcomings of debunking, NewsGuard designed its approach to be more proactive — pre-bunking a falsehood by providing people with instant information about the lack of reliability of the source that published it. Indeed, scientific research supports the effectiveness of NewsGuard’s intervention as a pre-bunking solution.

For example, in 2017, Indiana University researchers Alan Dennis and Antino Kim ran an investigation comparing different reputation rating formats to assess their ability to influence users’ belief in news articles. They found that presenting source reputation ratings directly influences the extent to which users believe articles on social media. In a 2019 article in The Conversation, Dennis and Kim said: “What we learned indicates that expert ratings provided by companies like NewsGuard are likely more effective at reducing the spread of propaganda and disinformation than having users rate the reliability and accuracy of news sources themselves.”

Separately, in their article “Neutralizing misinformation through inoculation: Exposing misleading argumentation techniques reduces their influence,” published in May 2017 in PLOS One, Stephan Lewandowsky, a psychologist at the University of Bristol, John Cook, a researcher at the Center for Climate Change Communication at George Mason University, and Ullrich Ecker, a cognitive psychologist at the University of Western Australia, explain how warnings about misinformation are more effective when they are administered before misinformation is encountered rather than after. This is because pre-existing beliefs impact how people respond to novel information. NewsGuard’s intervention of providing source-level evaluations when someone first encounters content can be described as “pre-bunking,” supporting the findings of Lewandowsky et. al’s study.

2. From the Covid Infodemic to Russian propaganda do you find any specific patterns in propagation of misinformation?

Our editorial team of trained journalists and misinformation specialists keep abreast of the global news and information landscape on a daily basis, and they have noticed that many misinformation publishers are repeat offenders. In other words, those perpetuating false hoaxes about COVID-19 vaccines, for example, are also likely to publish misinformation of other kinds, including false content about the Russian war in Ukraine. Similarly, websites that purported to publish “health advice” with misleading, scientifically-unproven remedies were some of the leading publishers of false COVID-19 information at the outbreak of the pandemic.

By evaluating these websites at the source level and tracking their editorial practices over time, NewsGuard offers a valuable tool for users, companies and democracies alike as our data proactively identifies repeat offenders and purveyors of misinformation ahead of the next wave of misinformation. No longer do users and content moderators have to wait for fact-checkers to retroactively debunk false claims: they can leverage “pre-bunking” data that protects them from forthcoming threats before they even arise.

3. No one has been spared from the Information Wars, which came as an added “bonus” of the Russian Invasion of Ukraine. How should people navigate through such information, and how can they distinguish actual facts vs false news?

Navigating the landscape of misinformation, particularly related to Russia’s war in Ukraine, is made increasingly complex by the rapid cadence of new false claims appearing each day. NewsGuard’s editorial team has been documenting daily the headlines on Russia’s Channel One about the war and debunking false claims spread about the conflict using information from authoritative sources.

By using tools like NewsGuard’s browser extension, internet users can see source context information on search results and on social media to aid them as they consider which sources might be trustworthy and which ones fail to adhere to basic journalistic standards. By consuming news from authoritative sources with high NewsGuard scores, users can help ensure that their news diet contains transparent, ethical journalism — rather than harmful misinformation and false claims.

4. Currently there are no particular regulations addressing misinformation, do you think associating fines to dissemination of misinformation might have an impact on limiting its spread?

At NewsGuard, we are proponents of user empowerment and believe that the greatest solution to combating misinformation is putting tools, context, and information in the hands of users, enabling them to make independent, informed decisions. When platforms block or censor content it stifles freedom of expression, but equally, they must be held accountable and implement effective trust and safety measures that empower and protect users who interact with and contribute to their platforms.

More posts like this

We want content moderation to enhance your users’ experience and so they can find their special one more easily.

Expert’s Corner with Head of Research Isabelle Augenstein

This month we were very happy to sit down with one of the brains behind Checkstep who is also a recognized talent among European academics. She is the co-head of research at Checkstep and also an associate professor at the University of Copenhagen. She currently holds a prestigious DFF Sapere Aude Research Leader fellowship on ‘Learning to…
5 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Community Building Expert Todd Nilson

Checkstep interviews expert in online community building Todd Nilson leads transformational technology projects for major brands and organizations. He specializes in online communities, digital workplaces, social listening analysis, competitive intelligence, game thinking, employer branding, and virtual collaboration. Todd has managed teams and engagements with national and global consultancy firms specialized in online communities and the…
7 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Checkstep CEO Guillaume Bouchard

This month’s expert is Checkstep’s CEO and Co-Founder Guillaume Bouchard. After exiting his previous company, Bloomsbury AI to Facebook, he’s on a mission to better prepare online platforms against all types of online harm. He has a PhD in applied mathematics and machine learning from INRIA, France. 12 years of scientific research experience at Xerox…
3 minutes

Misinformation Expert’s Corner : Preslav Nakov, AI and Fake News

Preslav Nakov has established himself as one of the leading experts on the use of AI against propaganda and disinformation. He has been very influential in the field of natural language processing and text mining, publishing hundreds of peer reviewed research papers. He spoke to us about his work dealing with the ongoing problem of…
8 minutes

AI Ethics Expert’s Corner : Kyle Dent, Head of AI Ethics

This month we’ve added a new “Expert’s Corner” feature starting with an interview with our own Kyle Dent, who recently joined Checkstep. He answers questions about AI ethics and some of the challenges of content moderation. AI Ethics FAQ with Kyle Dent If you would like to catch up on other thought leadership pieces by…
4 minutes

Expert’s Corner with T&S Expert Manpreet Singh

Our featured expert this month is someone who has been working hard to keep people safe online. Manpreet Singh is a Trust and Safety professional working in London, UK. She has developed her interest in Child Online Safety and Tech Policy through a myriad of experiences, including working as a policy researcher at a leading…
9 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Alexandra Koptyaeva

This month’s expert is Alexandra Koptyaeva. She wears many hats, one of which is the Trust and Safety Lead at Heyday. Alexandra has been working in Trust and Safety for over three and a half years starting in content moderation, investigations, and quality assurance, and later leading a team and managing company processes. Initially, she started…
9 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Zara Ward from Revenge Porn Helpline & Stop NCII

This month we had the pleasure of interviewing Zara Ward, senior practitioner at the Revenge Porn Helpline. What is the Revenue Porn Helpline? The Revenge Porn Helpline (RPH) is a part of the South West Grid for Learning charity and is a practical support service for adult (18+) victims in the UK who have been experiencing intimate image…
24 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Marketplace Risk Founder Jeremy Gottschalk

Jeremy Gottschalk is an expert in risk management and legal strategy for marketplace tech companies. With nearly 20 years of experience as a lawyer, operator and consultant to venture capitalists, founders and operators, he has become an industry-leading voice for legal strategy and risk management. Jeremy founded Marketplace Risk as an industry education, networking and knowledge-sharing platform for…
8 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Lauren Tharp from Tech Coalition

For this month’s Expert’s Corner we had the pleasure of interviewing Lauren Tharp from the Tech Coalition. The Tech Coalition is a global alliance of leading technology firms that have come together to combat online sexual abuse and exploitation of children. Because member companies have the same goals and face many of the same challenges,…
7 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Policy Principal Andrew Bennett

Andrew Bennett is a Policy Principal at Form Ventures, a U.K. VC fund investing in start-ups where regulation is a driver of success. Andrew’s expertise is in regulatory strategy, having worked across tech policy at the Tony Blair Institute and founded TxP, a network for people in tech and policy. How can online platforms keep up with…
4 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Subject Matter Expert Carolina Christofoletti

Carolina Christofoletti is a Child Sexual Abuse Material (CSAM) subject matter expert, with vast experience both in CSAM Intelligence and CSAM Trust & Safety. She currently leads the CSAM Blockchain Intelligence efforts at TRM Labs as part of the Threat Intelligence Team. Her career includes an extensive CSAM academic background starting in 2017 at University…
13 minutes

Expert’s Corner with CEO of Recluse Laboratories Andrew Johnston

Our expert this month is ex-FBIer Andrew Johnston. Andrew is the CEO and co-founder of Recluse Laboratories. Drawing on twelve years of experience in cybersecurity, Andrew has worked with clients both in an incident response capacity as well as in proactive services. In addition to his private sector work, at the Federal Bureau of Investigation,…
5 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Policy Consultant Ben Greenstone

We are extremely pleased to have had the chance to pick the brain of Ben Greenstone regarding the upcoming Online Safety Bill, which is new legislation making its way through Parliament in the U.K. Ben is the founder and Managing Director of Taso Advisory, a public policy consultancy with a focus on technology. Before setting…
4 minutes

Expert’s Corner with Head of Product Yu-Lan Scholliers

We recently spoke with Checkstep’s newest addition to the team, Yu-Lan Scholliers. She joins Checkstep from her recent position at Facebook where she was a Trust and Safety Specialist. She joins Checkstep as the Head of Operations. We asked her a bit about her background and interests to get to know her a little better.…
6 minutes

Prevent unwanted content from reaching your platform

Speak to one of our experts and learn about using AI to protect your platform
Talk to an expert